What do I do if my pecan pie is runny?

If your pecan pie is runny, it’s likely because you haven’t baked it long enough. It should bake for 60 to 70 minutes at 350F and then left to cool and set.

What causes a pecan pie to be runny in the middle?

A pecan pie is essentially a custard pie, and a liquid center is almost always the result of underbaking. The Karo Classic Pecan Pie recipe calls for baking the pie for 60 to 70 minutes at 350 degrees. In some ovens, however, the pie can take 75 minutes or more.

How do I make my pecan pie firmer?

Throw in a few extra pecans. In fact, that’s a good idea even if you don’t have trouble with runny pies. Add a fourth egg or a tablespoon of flour or cornstarch. Any of these options should make your pie filling more solid.

Can you overcook a pecan pie?

Pecan pie is notoriously difficult to bake because it can be difficult to tell when it is done. The crust and the pecans can burn easily if overcooked, but the middle can come out runny if it’s not cooked long enough.

Describe it.

It’s essential to understand what a pecan pie is and what consistency it should have before discussing the runny consistency. Pecan pie is a culinary pie with a sweet pastry crust and pecan nut filling.

A form of dairy-free custard made with sugar, eggs, butter, and dark or light corn syrup holds the nuts together. Usually, vanilla is used to taste it.

The custard mixture is then poured over the nuts in the pastry pie casing before the entire item is baked in the oven to set the filling. As the eggs cook, they induce the filling to set.

The center will be set, custardy, and almost jelly-like when it is finished. It shouldn’t be watery at all.

How To Make Pecan Pie Filling Thicker

The main cause of pecan pies failing to set correctly is underbaking. Additionally, adding flour would change the texture of the pecan pie filling if it were added to the recipe, despite the fact that many people recommend doing so to thicken the pie filling. But I don’t see how the flour would be added to a pie that has already been cooked for at least an hour if you bake it for the allotted time and it doesn’t set.

By carefully and exactly measuring all of the ingredients and baking the pie for the recommended amount of time, pecan pie filling can be thickened the best way possible. The pie filling should be close enough to the ideal consistency after refrigeration, even if it doesn’t set precisely so that it can be cut evenly and eaten with a fork.

Pecan pie’s shelf life is how long?

The ingredients that were used to make the pie and the type of storage conditions accessible after it has been baked are the main factors that affect how long it lasts. Egg-containing pecan pies should be refrigerated as soon as they are finished making and can last up to 4 days there.

However, if there are still a few portions of pecan pie after 4 days, they can be wrapped tightly in a double layer of plastic wrap and/or foil, put in an airtight plastic container, and frozen so they can be thawed and consumed later. However, if you have too many desserts and do not anticipate eating the remaining pecan pie within 4 days of baking, go ahead and freeze it as soon as possible while the pie’s quality is at its peak.

Pecan pie will keep for up to 6 months if carefully wrapped and frozen. It can defrost overnight in the refrigerator. However, if thawed at room temperature, it must be eaten right away.

What can you do to extend the life of a pecan pie?

A pecan pie’s storage life can be increased in a number of ways. They consist of:

  1. After roasting, refrigerate within two hours.
  2. If not chilled, keep the pie out of direct sunshine and away from any heat sources in a cool, dry place with a temperature of no higher than 40°F.
  3. Whether using foil, plastic wrap, or a suitable airtight container, keep the pie covered at all times (Amazon Recommendation).
  4. Use a serving spoon designed specifically for that pie when distributing it to prevent cross-contamination with other foods.
  5. When serving the pie after it has been chilled, try not to leave it out of the fridge for longer than two hours at a stretch.
  6. Pies that have been in the fridge for up to 4 days should either be thrown away or carefully covered and frozen so they can be served later.

Why Is My Pecan Pie Runny?


The filling will typically be runny because the eggs haven’t had a chance to solidify and the filling has been undercooked. The majority of recipes call for baking the pie for up to 60 to 70 minutes at a temperature of about 350 degrees Fahrenheit.

Nevertheless, based on the oven, the baking time can be extended to 75 minutes. If they need to extend the heating time, some folks lower the oven temperature to 325 degrees Fahrenheit.

You can simply cover the top of the pie with aluminum foil as it bakes if you are concerned about the pastry getting too brown.

Checked The Doneness Too Soon

Perhaps you have periodically looked to see if the pie filling is done and discovered that it is still runny. The custard surrounding the pecan layer won’t set until the pie filling hits 200 degrees Fahrenheit, so keep that in mind.

By pressing the pecans with the base of a spoon or your finger and feeling for a springback, you can determine whether they are done. If it does, the pie will not be runny and will be done.

On the other hand, it will have a runny substance if you don’t monitor the doneness and remove it before it’s finished.

False oven temperature

The temperature of the oven needs to be checked third. This is due to the fact that occasionally, the oven’s thermostat or thermometer malfunctions and displays an erroneous temperature. Pecan pie will have a runny consistency if it is baked at an erroneous temperature that is too low.

You should have the oven’s thermometer checked to see if it is correct before baking anything else. By heating the pie for longer, you might be able to fix the issue in the interim.

Not Cooked for Enough Time

Although baking times are specified in recipes, these times are only guidelines, and you might need to prepare the pie for longer. Here, exercise caution. If the pie contains eggs (we trust you remembered them), once the eggs have baked for a sufficient amount of time, the pie will undoubtedly be set.

The pie should be baked until the filling has set, covering it with a piece of aluminum foil if the pastry edges are getting too brown. Every ten minutes, check it.

Give it a rest.

When the mixture is still hot, most pecan pies are still a little shaky. You can be confident that it will still firm up once it has cooled down, as long as it isn’t watery.

First prepare the pastry crust.

The pecan pie crust should be partially baked before filling it for optimal results. This will guarantee a crust that is solid and not soggy. The best method is to “blind bake” the crust, which entails covering the uncooked pastry with a piece of baking paper and filling it with dried beans to weigh it down.

Verify the oven’s capacity for baking

Last but not least, if you’re investigating the cause of the watery pecan pie, your oven might be to blame. This is due to the uneven heating and baking of some older ovens, which causes inconsistent outcomes.

Therefore, it might be time to purchase a new oven or buy pecan pie from the bakery if your oven is old and you think it’s the problem.

Pie Dish Too Deep

We all enjoy pecan pies baked in deep dishes because each mouthful contains more of the delicious filling, but this might be the source of your issue. Pie baked in a deep container will take longer to set.

We advise cooking your pie longer and lower while reducing the oven temperature if you plan to use one.

A recipe without eggs

Because eggs are what make the pie filling solidify, it must contain eggs. You will have a runny pie that won’t set no matter how long you bake it if you neglected to add them in or left them out because someone in your family is allergic.

There are vegan pie recipes that set the mixture with cornstarch and flax eggs. Consider looking for one of these.

Best Ever Pecan Pie Filling Recipe

Here is a recipe for classic pecan pie filling that is sure to set because it contains plenty of eggs. It’s delectable and certain to become a household staple.


  • three big, beaten eggs
  • 1/4 cup sugary maize syrup
  • quarter cup mild brown sugar
  • 1 and a half tablespoons of vanilla extract or essence
  • 3 tablespoons butter, melted
  • A dash of salt
  • 2 cups of coarsely chopped pecan pecans


  • Bake the dough in advance until it just begins to turn golden.
  • Beat the eggs, molasses, brown sugar, vanilla, and butter in a measuring cup. include the screws
  • After the crust has finished baking, gently drizzle the nutty syrup over it.
  • When the pie has firmed up, bake it in the heated oven at 350°F for about an hour.
  • Before serving, let it cool at room temperature for at least an hour and ideally two. When served immediately, it will be too watery.

FAQs (Related Question)

Why is my pie soupy?

Pay attention to bake times: one reason you’ll often end up with a runny fruit pie is simply that it hasn’t been baked long enough. Any thickener you use needs a little time to set up, and people often see their crust turning light brown and think the pie is done when it’s really not. 3.

Is pecan pie supposed to be gooey?

The center should jiggle a little, but it should have some stability. If the pie filling shows horizontal movement on shaking, then it is not done yet.

Can you put a pie back in the oven after cooling?

This is a tricky problem to fix, but hope is not lost. If it’s a fruit pie, try putting it back in the oven for a few minutes on the very bottom rack, thus putting the underbaked bottom closer to the heat source. If it’s a custard pie, don’t try to re-bake it; you risk compromising your lovely filling.

How do you know if a pecan pie is set?

Look for the moment when the center of your pecan pie gives you just a little jiggle—like the stable but slightly wiggly movement of Jell-O when you give it a gentle shake—but the edges are stable and set.

Does pecan pie set up after baking?

Once you hit this sweet spot, take your slightly jiggly pecan pie out of the oven and place it on a wire cooling rack. The filling will continue to cook and fully set as the pie cools. Let your pie finish setting and cool completely for at least two hours.

How do you know when pecan pie is done baking?

Pecan pie is done at the first signs of solidity in the center of the pie (center should not shake and a knife inserted in the center will come out clean). The internal temperature of a pecan pan when done should register 200 degrees F. (93 degrees C.) on your cooking thermometer.

How do you thicken a runny pie filling?

Bake the pie until the filling juices are visibly bubbling through the vents in the pie crust. Thickeners like cornstarch need to reach the point of boiling before they are activated. >> Cool the pie completely before serving, as it needs that time to set up.

How much cornstarch do I add to pie filling?

Use less thickening for open-faced pies

For a lattice or open-faced pie, use a little less thickening than for a double crust pie, because more of the liquid will evaporate during the baking process. The average amount of cornstarch for 4 ounces of fruit is 1 to 2 teaspoons.

How do you thicken a pie filling?

When thickening a fruit pie filling, there are several options to consider. Very often flour or cornstarch is used, but in certain instances tapioca, arrowroot and potato starch can also help achieve the desired consistency.

How long does a pecan pie take to set?

Bake on preheated cookie sheet 35 to 45 minutes or until center is set. After 15 to 20 minutes of baking, cover crust edge with strips of foil to prevent excessive browning. Cool 30 minutes; refrigerate at least 2 hours until chilled before serving. Cover and refrigerate any remaining pie.

Does pecan pie need to be refrigerated after baking?

Yes. Because pecan pie is an “egg-rich” pie, the USDA recommends you store it in the fridge after it has cooled. Unless you plan on serving the pie within two hours of baking, it shouldn’t stay out at room temperature.

Why isn’t my pecan pie setting?

The center jiggles more than it’s supposed to. Why didn’t the filling set properly? If your pecan pie is still a little soupy, it simply means you need to bake it more. The center or filling of a pecan pie needs time to thicken and set properly.

How do you fix undercooked pie?

If your pie is undercooked: Cover it with aluminum foil, pop it back in the oven, and bake at 425 F for about 15 minutes (or until done). Remember to do the doneness test before cooling. Then top with whipped cream. Easy as pie!

Can I Rebake a soggy pie?

How to Fix Soggy Pie Crust | Thanksgiving Recipes